In my opinion it was a senseless, tragic lose. The cruelty of the judges was not necessary. The rude comments online were inhuman and was one of the main reasons she died. I think Paula Abdul was innocent and was more caring than the other judges. I also think Paula G. must of had some mental issues to change her name and lifestyle. Obviously she needed some help since it came to taking her life. I am glad American Idol is now giving the contestants more helpful criticism. American Idol remains a popular TV show year after year.