I think Abigail would be most like Regina George from Mean Girls only because she is known for lying. In the play, Abigail is also known for her two faced personality.

ABIGAIL

REV. PARRIS

Modern Version

I think Rev. Parris would look like an important businessman or politician with a great life on the outside but problems on the inside. He would be someone who makes sure his image looks better than what it actually is.