Morally Best decision

Utilitarianism

Aristotelian Ethics

Catholic Ethical
Perspective

I believe the morally best decision is Kantian ethics. In a situation like this it is best to take all consequences and factors completely out of the situation. You are left witch a choice. Stay true to yourself or go against what you stand for. The most moral decision in to stay true to oneself. This system is very clear cut and provides a simple and morally just choice.

Even as a benevolent spectator is is hard to gauge the pleasure of one side over the other. This blurs the lines between the decisions and makes the morally right choice harder to see

With Aristotle it is always harder to define the scale of the situation. In this case it is being true to oneself or not. It is hard to not put yourself in the situation to say which is more opposed to the mean because it is different for everyone

Through this system your have to evaluate and break down the moral and immoral choices. This system provides a good answer to the question but leaves some moral gaps that are left unanswered.